Socialism and social democracy: analysis of 13 November 2026

Back to the Chronology · Current news in this section

Photo from Bernie Sanders says he won’t support Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader, NBC News

Analysis

A record cohort of American democratic socialists moves from insurgency to governing power while Bernie Sanders opens a fight over Senate leadership, even as Spain's Socialists face a snap election whose outcome polls and markets read in opposite directions.

The week's dominant story is the consolidation of the US left's midterm gains: a historic number of Democratic Socialists of America members won mayoralties, state legislative seats and congressional races, and the Democrats secured at least 54 Senate seats 91828. That success immediately produced an intra-party struggle, with Sanders and Elissa Slotkin calling for new Senate leadership and Sanders signalling support for Chris Van Hollen against Chuck Schumer 11622. In New York, Zohran Mamdani's handling of a fatal Brooklyn building collapse offers an early test of socialist administration rather than socialist campaigning 3814, while Republican officials in Florida are moving to frame the DSA as a foreign-influenced threat 152. In Europe, Spain's Socialists enter a snap election with the state pollster showing them ahead but markets and other reports expecting a right-wing victory, amid mass housing-cost protests 512, and Britain's extra-Labour left is consolidating organisationally 2519.

Key developments

  • Sanders challenges Schumer's leadership. Sanders announced he will not support Schumer for majority leader and said he would back Van Hollen if he runs; Slotkin also called for new leadership, though neither named an alternative at first [1][16]. Schumer expressed confidence despite what the Guardian describes as dwindling votes [28]. Sanders's stated rationale in The Nation, a progressive outlet, is that Schumer is 'way out of touch' with the public [22], making this a contest over whether the midterm mandate belongs to the party establishment or to the economic-populist wing credited by El País with supplying the winning message [10]. 116222810
  • Democratic socialists take municipal and legislative office. A record number of DSA members will become mayors, alongside gains in Congress and state legislatures, and the Guardian frames their task as proving an 'affordability' agenda in practice [9]. NPR's interview with historian Jill Lepore argues the DSA is no longer 'beyond the political pale' [18], and Al Jazeera reports progressive strategists treating Mamdani's 2025 campaign as a model for 2028 [17]. This shifts the left's burden from mobilisation to delivery, a transition that has historically tested socialist movements. 91817
  • Mamdani's governing test in Brooklyn. A three-storey residential building adjacent to a construction site collapsed in Brooklyn, killing at least eight people including two children and injuring 17, with about 250 first responders deployed and law enforcement leading the investigation into the cause [6][8][14]. Mamdani fronted the response, emphasising that responders arrived within a minute and calling the deaths 'senseless' [13][3]. Crisis management of this kind is where a socialist mayor's competence is judged by voters far outside his base, and the cause is not yet established. 3681314
  • Republican counter-mobilisation targets the DSA. Florida's attorney general issued an investigative subpoena to the DSA over alleged Chinese and Cuban government support, announced via social media video; no evidence is reported in the item [15]. Separately, Rep. Carlos Gimenez invited Musk to relocate Tesla from Texas to Florida, explicitly citing the election of 'self-described Democratic Socialists' in Texas and a clash with incoming Governor Gina Hinojosa [2]. Together these indicate a Republican strategy of delegitimising the left through foreign-influence framing and capital-flight signalling rather than policy debate. 152
  • Spain's Socialists face a contested election picture. The state pollster CIS gives Sánchez's Socialists 33.3% and a 7.8-point lead as the campaign opens, while The Rio Times notes markets favour the PP and Vox [5], and The Hindu reports the right-wing opposition is widely expected to win [12]. Huge housing-cost rallies, some ending in clashes with police, are read as a measure of discontent [12]. The divergence between the government-linked pollster and other expectations should be treated as unresolved. 512
  • Pro-Palestine politics enters the ballot box. Providence, Rhode Island, became the largest US city to divest from Israel and the first to do so by popular vote, with the Guardian and Jacobin linking the measure to the election of socialist officials [26][29]. In Britain, Jeremy Corbyn pressed Prime Minister Andy Burnham on Gaza at Prime Minister's Questions, in an account from the socialist Morning Star that criticises government inaction [19]. Foreign-policy dissent is becoming a shared organising axis for the Anglo-American left. 262919

Currents of the left

  • Reforming private law versus confronting the wage relation. Jacobin's critique of Katharina Pistor's thesis that capitalism is a legal regime alterable through private law insists that any programme ignoring labour exploitation leaves capitalism's core intact [24]. This is a classic Marxist-versus-institutionalist dispute over whether structural change can be achieved through legal design or requires transformation of production relations. 24
  • Does social democracy cause stagnation?. Law & Liberty, a free-market outlet, argues that social democracy's 'increasingly wild promises' rather than markets explain economic stagnation [31], a position directly contradicted by the affordability-centred case made by the Guardian and El País for the left's electoral success [9][10]. The disagreement is about causality and is unresolved by the items. 31910
  • Identity politics or class politics?. New Lines frames Muslim progressives' wins as the 'slow death of identity politics' [21], and Jacobin stresses El-Sayed's everyday cultural fluency [4]. Both outlets are advancing a thesis that economic and cultural common ground, not group representation, drove victories; this is an interpretation, not a demonstrated causal account. 214
  • Consolidation on the British extra-Labour left. Left Unity, the British affiliate of the European Left Party, has affiliated to Your Party, with the Morning Star noting Left Unity lost momentum when Corbyn led Labour [25]. With Burnham as prime minister and Corbyn pressing him on Gaza [19], the question is whether a Labour government under a soft-left figure absorbs or further provokes a separate socialist pole. 2519

Themes

  • From protest to administration. The US left's victories [9][18] and Mamdani's crisis role [3][8] shift attention to delivery, exemplified by Jacobin's 'sewer socialist' PowerNYC proposal for a public clean-energy developer [23]. The Guardian's framing of mayors needing to 'prove' affordability [9] captures the vulnerability: governing socialists are judged on outputs, not slogans. 9183823
  • Economic populism as the left's answer to right populism. El País credits Sanders's 'kitchen table populism' for Democratic gains [10], while Jacobin reads ballot measures on billionaire taxes and divestment as evidence of a receptive electorate [20]; coverage of El-Sayed and other Muslim progressives argues cultural rapport and class messaging are displacing identity politics [4][21]. Jacobin nonetheless warns that a more disciplined far-right figure in J. D. Vance could inherit a weakened MAGA movement [30]. 102042130
  • The right's delegitimisation playbook. Florida's subpoena [15], Gimenez's appeal to Musk [2], and the free-market outlet Law & Liberty's argument that social democracy's promises cause stagnation [31] represent three registers of attack: security, capital mobility and economic theory. These are viewpoint-driven interventions rather than established findings and should be read as such. 15231

By region

  • North America. The US left has emerged from the midterms with unprecedented office-holding, a Senate leadership fight, and immediate governing tests [9][1][3]. Republican responses in Florida and Texas suggest the socialist label will be central to the 2028 contest, which Jacobin expects Vance to shape [15][2][30]. 913152
  • Europe. Spain's Socialists enter a snap election with conflicting signals from the state pollster and markets amid housing protests [5][12]. In Britain, a Labour government under Burnham faces pressure from Corbyn and a consolidating extra-parliamentary left [19][25], while a scholarly study on heritage after state socialism in Eastern Europe recalls the region's distinct post-socialist trajectory [33]. 512192533
  • Middle East. Gaza features only as an object of Western left politics: Providence's divestment vote [26][29] and Corbyn's parliamentary questioning [19] show Palestine solidarity functioning as a mobilising issue for socialist movements rather than as regional reporting. 262919

Analytical lenses

  • Populism as a thin-centred ideology. The concept holds that populism pits 'the people' against an elite and attaches to thicker host ideologies; El País's 'kitchen table populism' [10] and Sanders's charge that Schumer is 'out of touch' [22] show the left adopting the anti-elite frame with a social-democratic host, in competition with the MAGA variant Jacobin fears Vance will refine [30]. The lens explains the shared rhetorical form but misses the policy substance, such as PowerNYC and billionaire taxes, that distinguishes the two [23][20]. 1022302320
  • Municipal socialism and the 'sewer socialist' tradition. Early twentieth-century American socialists won by delivering competent, visible public services; Jacobin's PowerNYC proposal invokes this explicitly [23], and Mamdani's emergency response [13][8] and the Guardian's affordability framing [9] fit the pattern of legitimacy through administration. The lens explains why delivery matters more than ideology for these mayors, but it underplays how state-level and federal hostility, as in Florida's subpoena [15], can constrain city governments. 23138915
  • Securitisation of domestic opposition. Securitisation theory describes moving an issue from ordinary politics into the realm of existential threat; Florida's foreign-funding subpoena against the DSA [15] and Gimenez's linkage of socialists in office to capital flight [2] perform this move on an electoral competitor. The lens captures the strategy's logic but cannot by itself say whether audiences accept it, which NPR's claim that the DSA is no longer 'beyond the pale' suggests may be weakening [18]. 15218

What to watch

  • Whether Van Hollen formally enters the Senate leadership race and whether Slotkin's call signals centrist as well as left defection from Schumer [1][16][28]. 11628
  • The official finding on the Brooklyn collapse's cause, given the building's proximity to a construction site and the political stakes for Mamdani's administration [6][14]. 614
  • Spain's snap election result this month, which will test whether the CIS lead or the market and media expectation of a PP–Vox victory proves correct, and how housing anger translates into votes [5][12]. 512
  • AOC's decision between a 2028 presidential run and a Senate path, now that her team has been reshuffled twice [11], and whether the DSA contests the Florida subpoena [15]. 1115
Stories this analysis is based on (30)
  1. Bernie Sanders says he won’t support Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader NBC News
  2. House Republican invites Musk to move Tesla HQ to Florida The Hill
  3. Mamdani says eight people ‘senselessly’ died in NYC building collapse NBC News
  4. Abdul El-Sayed’s Sports Fluency Is a Political Asset Jacobin (socialist)
  5. Spain Poll Puts Sánchez 7.8 Points Ahead The Rio Times
  6. New York building collapse kills at least eight as rescuers search rubble The National (UAE)
  7. Brooklyn building collapse kills at least 8 and injures 17 as search continues The Guardian World
  8. A record number of US democratic socialists will become mayors. They’re out to prove their vision for affordability The Guardian US Politics
  9. ‘Economic populism is very fashionable’: the old Bernie Sanders formula that helped Democrats win the midterms El País English
  10. Scoop: AOC shakes up team again as 2028 decision looms Axios
  11. Protesters clash with police in Spain after huge housing cost rallies The Hindu International
  12. Building collapse in Brooklyn kills two, injures more than a dozen Al Jazeera
  13. At least two people dead in Brooklyn partial building collapse NBC News
  14. Did China and Cuba fund US socialists? Florida’s attorney general demands answers SCMP China
  15. Sanders: 'I will support' Van Hollen for majority leader if he runs The Hill
  16. Zohran Mamdani’s influence grows as Democrats eye 2028 strategies Al Jazeera
  17. What's behind Democratic Socialists' historic victories in the midterms? NPR
  18. So much Palestine needs, so much Britain could do Morning Star (socialist daily)
  19. What Ballot Measures Told Us About America Jacobin (socialist)
  20. After the Midterms, America Is Getting Politicians Who Live Like Me New Lines Magazine
  21. Exclusive: Bernie Sanders on Why It’s Vital for Democrats to Replace Chuck Schumer The Nation (progressive)
  22. A Sewer Socialist Proposal for the Climate: PowerNYC Jacobin (socialist)
  23. Capitalism Is More Than a Legal Regime Jacobin (socialist)
  24. Left Unity joins Your Party as affiliate Morning Star (socialist daily)
  25. How a small, newly socialist US city became the second to cut ties with Israel The Guardian Gaza
  26. Schumer confident on Senate leadership role despite dwindling votes – video The Guardian US
  27. Providence Built a Winning Movement to Divest From Israel Jacobin (socialist)
  28. Trump’s Midterm Rout Didn’t End the Threat From J. D. Vance Jacobin (socialist)
  29. The Dangerous Twilight of Social Democracy Law & Liberty
  30. Heritage transitions in Eastern Europe: urban conservation from late state socialism into its aftermath Journal articles (OpenAlex)

Written by Claude Fable 5.1 (Anthropic), based on 33 recent headlines and excerpts in this section, Nov 13. AI analysis can misread or miss things: the numbers link to the original reporting, which is the authority.