Capitalism and its critics: analysis of 16 November 2026
Back to the Chronology · Current news in this section

Analysis
Artificial intelligence has become the central battleground in the political economy of capitalism this week, with critics on the left framing it as speculative 'disaster capitalism' while liberal and free-market voices debate whether public listings, state capacity or market discipline can govern i
The week's items cluster around three debates: how AI's capital boom should be governed and who bears its financial and democratic risks (1, 9, 13, 15, 18, 24); a renewed contest over the proper scope of the state, pitting Mazzucato- and Weber-style interventionism against free-market defenders of growth and price signals (19, 20, 21, 22); and the fragmentation of class-based politics, visible in South Africa's ANC decline, Spain's housing-driven general strike and generational shifts in American attitudes towards socialism (2, 4, 12). Running underneath is the question of private infrastructural power, from Starlink's role in Ukraine to the financialisation of city governance (5, 23). Most items come from avowedly socialist (Jacobin) or free-market (Adam Smith Institute) outlets, so their diagnoses should be read as positions in an argument rather than settled findings.
Key developments
- AI framed as the new disaster capitalism. Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor, in an Al Jazeera podcast, characterise the AI investment boom as a bubble built on authoritarian politics and ask what will burst it, while Jacobin argues that the 'misalignment' AI firms warn about is really a profit-driven 'predatory computational power' (1, 9). The significance is that the left has shifted from critiquing platform capitalism's data extraction to targeting AI's capital structure itself; a European populism-studies commentary offers a more Schumpeterian framing of 'creative destruction' with financial risks and democratic resilience at stake (18). 1918
- Anthropic IPO and the financialisation of AI safety. Project Syndicate argues that when frontier labs go public, ordinary savers' pensions become tied to their valuations, so that catastrophic safety failures would destroy shareholder value as surely as over-regulation might stifle growth (13). This reframes AI safety as a question of corporate governance and systemic financial risk, connecting to concerns that a bursting bubble would socialise losses (1, 18) and to Jacobin's call for state and local regulation as a route to eventual federal action it says the midterms showed voters want (15). 1311815
- Starlink and private control of strategic infrastructure. US Senators Shaheen and Coons demanded that Elon Musk preserve SpaceX records on restrictions to Ukraine's Starlink and Starshield access, with a 30 November deadline, while Congressmen Meeks and Smith warned the restrictions contributed to Ukrainian civilian deaths, a claim that remains an allegation rather than an established finding (5). The episode illustrates how privately owned networks have become quasi-sovereign actors, a theme Verfassungsblog develops in analysing 'tech power's violence' against democratic deliberation (24). 524
- The scope-of-the-state debate reopens. An excerpt from Isabella Weber's Anti-Fascist Economics argues mainstream economics has ignored survival-level 'essentials' and advocates a politics of guaranteeing them, while the free-market Adam Smith Institute mocks both Weber and Mariana Mazzucato as reviving century-old planning ideas and defends growth and economic orthodoxy against Guardian-style critics (19, 20, 22). The Institute also frames free trade versus protectionism as the salient case where 'sound' economics meets political resistance (21), a framing that itself embeds a free-market viewpoint. 19202122
- Class dealignment from South Africa to Spain. Jacobin reports that South Africa's local elections show the ANC losing its working-class base to right-wing parties after three decades of economic failure, and separately that Spain's general strike, following mass housing protests, has cohered a militant class-based movement (2, 12). Axios adds that American Gen Z is breaking with inherited orthodoxies on socialism, Israel and Christianity (4), suggesting that dissatisfaction with existing capitalist settlements is being channelled in sharply different partisan directions across regions. 2124
- Dollar hegemony decoupled from oil. Jacobin argues the dollar's global role stemmed from US preeminence rather than petrodollar arrangements, and that slow erosion of US power will not automatically end the dollar system (17). This matters for debates on state capitalism and de-dollarisation, since it implies that challengers would need to replicate the institutional depth of US financial markets, not merely redirect commodity trade. 17
Debates over capitalism
- Left critiques of AI capital. Klein and Taylor's 'disaster capitalism' framing and Jacobin's 'misalignment is capitalism' argument treat the AI boom as speculative and politically authoritarian, rejecting the industry's own safety discourse as misdirection (1, 9). Jacobin nonetheless advocates incremental state and local regulation as a stepping stone, indicating pragmatism alongside systemic critique (15). 1915
- Free-market defence of growth and prices. The Adam Smith Institute, a free-market think tank, argues that disagreement with economics reflects ignorance rather than insight, that growth sceptics are mistaken, and that interventionists like Mazzucato and Weber would revive discredited price controls (19, 22). Its framing of protectionism as politics obstructing economic logic presents a contested normative position as settled science (21). 192122
- Post-neoliberal interventionism. Weber's 'politics of essentials' and the implied Mazzucato programme argue that general-equilibrium economics obscured problems of survival and that the state should guarantee essentials, which Weber frames as anti-fascist economics (20, 19). Verfassungsblog's analysis of cities governing like financial actors supplies an institutionalist complement, locating financialisation in urban land regulation (23). 201923
- Conservative self-reassessment. ConservativeHome's Jack Peters argues the Conservatives failed not from excess liberalism but from weakness, and that invoking Thatcher as a 'comfort blanket' misreads her success (10). This intra-right debate over whether to double down on market liberalism or project strength parallels the Gen Z shifts Axios describes, where old loyalties no longer bind (4). 104
Themes
- Tech power as a sovereignty problem. Across the Starlink records dispute, critiques of AI as profit-driven computational power and analyses of social media corroding deliberation, the recurring concern is that privately owned infrastructure now exercises powers once reserved to states (5, 9, 24). Responses diverge between regulatory pressure through capital markets and public listing (13), subnational regulation (15) and more radical restructuring (1, 9). 59131524
- Reform versus rupture on the left. Jacobin's critique of Katharina Pistor's 'code of capital' thesis insists that rewiring private law leaves the wage relation untouched, echoing its tribute to Marxist economist Guglielmo Carchedi and its reading of Debs as rooting socialism in American democratic traditions (11, 6, 8). The same tension shapes its treatment of reactionary feminists and of play under capitalism, where cultural critique is tested against a materialist standard (16, 3). 1168163
- Contested lessons of economic failure. South Africa's post-apartheid settlement, Britain's Conservatives revisiting Thatcher and Spain's housing crisis are all read as verdicts on capitalist governance, yet the beneficiaries range from the far right to militant socialists to a reasserted free-market right (2, 10, 12). This supports the view that economic discontent is politically underdetermined and depends on which organisations can claim it. 21012
By region
- North America. US debates centre on AI governance, from the Anthropic IPO to subnational regulation and the 'disaster capitalism' critique, alongside congressional scrutiny of Musk's Starlink decisions (13, 15, 1, 9, 5). Axios reports Gen Z abandoning inherited positions on socialism, while Jacobin revisits Debs to root socialism in American democratic traditions (4, 8). 1315195
- Europe. Spain's general strike after housing protests marks a mobilisation of class politics, while British debate runs between the Adam Smith Institute's free-market defence and Weber's interventionism, and the Conservatives reassess their Thatcherite inheritance (12, 19, 20, 22, 10). Verfassungsblog contributes analyses of financialised city governance and tech power's corrosion of deliberation (23, 24). 1219202210
- East Asia. Jacobin reviews Lee Chang-dong's Possible Love as a study of class in the aftermath of a real-life strike defeat in South Korea, a coordinated-capitalist economy where labour conflict has long been politically salient (7). It is the only East Asian item and reflects a cultural rather than policy register. 7
- Africa. Jacobin argues South Africa's local elections show the ANC's working-class base defecting to right-wing parties after three decades of economic failure (2). The outlet's prescription of rebuilding working-class power is a socialist viewpoint; the underlying realignment nonetheless signals the exhaustion of the post-apartheid developmental compact. 2
Analytical lenses
- Polanyi's double movement. The concept of society pushing back against market expansion illuminates Spain's housing strike, Weber's politics of essentials and the backlash against AI that Jacobin says the midterms revealed (12, 20, 15). It is less able to explain why, in South Africa, the counter-movement benefits the right rather than redistributive forces, which points to the role of organisational capacity and nativism (2). 1220152
- Financialisation and shareholder governance. Treating AI firms as objects of pension-fund exposure, cities as financial actors, and the dollar as a product of institutional depth rather than oil, the financialisation lens explains how risk is distributed and why regulation now runs through capital markets (13, 23, 17). It captures incentives but says little about the labour and wage relation that Jacobin insists is capitalism's core (11, 6). 132317116
- Infrastructural power and private sovereignty. Drawing on the concept of infrastructural power, the Starlink dispute and the analysis of tech power's violence show private firms exercising control over communications and deliberation that states once monopolised (5, 24, 9). The lens clarifies the governance gap but does not resolve whether the remedy is state capacity, as interventionists argue, or market competition, as free-marketeers prefer (20, 19). 52492019
What to watch
- Whether SpaceX confirms preservation of Starlink records by the 30 November deadline, and whether congressional scrutiny extends into formal limits on private control of defence-critical networks (5). 5
- How an Anthropic public listing is received by markets and regulators, since it would test whether shareholder exposure strengthens or dilutes AI safety incentives (13, 18). 1318
- The outcome and follow-through of Spain's general strike and whether housing-based mobilisation translates into durable political organisation rather than a one-off protest (12). 12
- Post-election realignment in South Africa, where the ANC's loss of working-class support to the right will shape whether economic frustration feeds nativist or redistributive programmes (2). 2
Stories this analysis is based on (23)
- Fascism built the AI bubble. What will burst it? Al Jazeera
- South Africa’s ANC Is Collapsing. The Far Right Is Rising. Jacobin (socialist)
- Under Capitalism, Even Kids’ Playtime Is Alienated Jacobin (socialist)
- Gen Z shatters America's political orthodoxies Axios
- US Senators Demand Musk Preserve Records on Ukraine’s Starlink Access, Set Nov. 30 Deadline Kyiv Post
- Guglielmo Carchedi Was a Pathbreaking Marxist Economist Jacobin (socialist)
- Possible Love Is a Cinematic Masterpiece About Class Jacobin (socialist)
- Eugene Debs’s Life Speaks to Today’s Socialist Movement Jacobin (socialist)
- The Real AI Misalignment Problem Is Capitalism Jacobin (socialist)
- Jack Peters: The Conservatives weren’t too liberal: we were too weak ConservativeHome
- Capitalism Is More Than a Legal Regime Jacobin (socialist)
- On Strike for a Different Spain Jacobin (socialist)
- Will Anthropic’s IPO Lead to Better AI Regulation? Project Syndicate
- An Effective AI Pushback Has to Go Beyond the Local Jacobin (socialist)
- Reactionary Feminists Offer Bad Solutions to Real Problems Jacobin (socialist)
- The Dollar’s Power Never Came From Oil Jacobin (socialist)
- Governing AI’s Creative Destruction: Shared Prosperity, Financial Risks, and Democratic Resilience European Center for Populism Studies
- Do we really want malaria back in Bristol? Adam Smith Institute (free-market)
- A Politics of Essentials Phenomenal World
- Where economics and politics collide Adam Smith Institute (free-market)
- It’s not knowing economics that makes people disagree with it Adam Smith Institute (free-market)
- Claims to the City Verfassungsblog
- Tech Power’s Violence Verfassungsblog
Written by Claude Fable 5.1 (Anthropic), based on 24 recent headlines and excerpts in this section, 4d ago. AI analysis can misread or miss things: the numbers link to the original reporting, which is the authority.