Ideologies around the world: analysis of 11 November 2026

Back to the Chronology · Current news in this section

Photo from Bernie Sanders says he won’t support Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader, NBC News

Analysis

After Trump's midterm defeat, each ideological family is re-reading the moment: populists ask if their wave is retreating, the left fights over leadership, and conservatives fight over their future.

This week's ideological debate is dominated by the aftermath of the US midterms. Commentators ask whether right-wing populism is retreating, while others warn that J.D. Vance and far-right activists inside the GOP remain a threat. On the left, Sanders refused to back Schumer, EU socialists pushed for common defence, and Jacobin celebrates a divestment movement. Conservatives are debating their direction in Britain, South Korea and the US, from Badenoch's benefits policy to an AI-skills agenda. In Europe, nationalism and the far right show up in Poland's anti-migrant backlash and a Kraków attack with right-wing extremist traces, and in Spain's debate over a coalition with Vox. Classical liberals at Law & Liberty and Reason warn about the twilight of social democracy and illiberal labour law. The Pope's veiled rebuke of Milei's austerity brings religion into the debate over neoliberalism.

Key developments

  • Is populism retreating?. Commentators ask whether right-wing populism is set to retreat after the midterms, while Jacobin and The American Conservative argue that Vance remains a powerful heir to Trumpism. 14166
  • Fights on the left. Sanders refused to back Schumer, EU socialists pushed common defence and support for Kyiv, and Jacobin profiles a winning divestment movement in Providence. 11913
  • Conservatives regroup. Jim Jordan, a 'pugnacious Trump ideologue', will lead House Republicans, Britain's Conservatives debate Badenoch's benefits crackdown and an AI-skills agenda, and South Korea's conservatives face a proxy battle. 6152829
  • The far right in Europe. Poland faces an anti-migrant backlash and a gunman fascinated by Breivik, Spain's Feijóo says a coalition with Vox is not up to him, and WIRED reports far-right extremists trying to take over the GOP. 5242718
  • Liberal and libertarian critiques. Law & Liberty warns of the 'dangerous twilight of social democracy' and labour law's illiberal turn, and Reason fears a Democratic wave threatens originalism. 384021
  • Faith and austerity. Pope Leo XIV delivered a veiled rebuke of Milei's austerity, and analysts describe a new geopolitics of faith in Latin America. 444

The ideologies this week

  • Populism. Debate centres on whether the wave is ebbing after the midterms, or whether Vance and online activists will carry it on. 141618
  • Socialism and social democracy. Socialists push common EU defence while liberal critics warn that social democracy is in twilight. 1938
  • Conservatism. Conservatives in Britain, South Korea and the US are divided over welfare, technology and leadership. 152829
  • Nationalism. Studies of national heroes in Romanian and Moldovan textbooks and White Christian nationalism in the US show nationalism as an identity project. 3133
  • Neoliberalism. The Pope's rebuke of Milei's austerity revives the moral critique of market reform. 4

By region

  • North America. The midterms reshuffle both parties' leaderships and fuel debate over the future of Trumpism. 1616
  • Europe. Anti-migrant backlash in Poland, Vox in Spain and budget fights over Ukraine shape European ideological battles. 52717
  • Latin America. Lula's digital mobilisation and the Pope's critique of Milei frame the left–right contest. 324
  • East Asia. South Korea's conservatives are fighting a proxy battle over their future. 29

Themes

  • Elections as ideological tests. The US midterms and Lula's victory are being read by every camp as evidence for its own diagnosis, from the right's lessons to the left's digital mobilisation. 203214
  • Courts and backsliding. Scholars ask when courts constrain democratic backsliding and point to Serbia's student movement as proof that ethnonationalism is not destiny. 3435

Analytical lenses

  • Thermostatic public opinion. Voters move against whoever holds power, which explains the midterm swing against Trump. It misses how ideological activists, like the far right inside the GOP, can still radicalise a party in defeat. 1418
  • Cleavage theory. Migration and national identity form a new cleavage that cuts across left and right, visible in Poland and Spain. It explains the far right's staying power; it says less about economic issues such as austerity and wealth taxes. 5274

What to watch

  • Whether Spain's conservatives form a coalition with Vox. 27
  • How Vance positions himself as the post-midterm leader of the populist right. 16
  • Whether Teddy Riner's candidacy reshapes France's presidential race. 2
Stories this analysis is based on (26)
  1. Bernie Sanders says he won’t support Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader NBC News
  2. French judo star Teddy Riner announces run for presidency Africanews
  3. Pope delivers veiled rebuke of Milei's austerity measures BBC Latin America
  4. Poland’s anti-migrant backlash UnHerd
  5. Who is Jim Jordan? Pugnacious Trump ideologue to lead diminished Republican ranks The Guardian US
  6. Providence Built a Winning Movement to Divest From Israel Jacobin (socialist)
  7. Is right-wing populism set to retreat? The Hindu International
  8. Call it tough love, with the love removed: it’s Kemi’s war on benefits claimants The Guardian Conservatives
  9. Trump’s Midterm Rout Didn’t End the Threat From J. D. Vance Jacobin (socialist)
  10. Merz accused of ‘blackmail’ by Slovak PM after demand for Ukraine aid in EU budget The Guardian World
  11. ‘We Have to Take Over’: Far-Right Extremists Want to Seize Control of the GOP WIRED
  12. EXCLUSIVE: EU socialists push common defence, double down on Kyiv Euractiv
  13. The Right Lessons From Brazil and the US Project Syndicate
  14. New in Civitas: "The Blue Tsunami Threatens To Drown Originalism" Reason (libertarian)
  15. Poland gunman fascinated by Norway’s neo-Nazi mass killer Breivik Al Jazeera
  16. Alberto Núñez Feijóo, Spain’s opposition leader: ‘Whether a coalition government with Vox is formed does not depend on me’ El País English
  17. Noah Avis: The Conservative case for an AI-skilled generation ConservativeHome
  18. South Korea’s Conservatives Are Moving Toward a Proxy Battle Over Their Future The Diplomat
  19. Pantheon(s) of National Heroes: A Content Analysis of History Textbooks in Post/Socialist Romania and the Republic of Moldova Nations and Nationalism (journal)
  20. Lula’s digital army Latinoamérica21
  21. “A New Founding Text for Our People”: White Christian Nationalism and Tolkien’s Mythopoeia Illiberalism Studies Program (GWU)
  22. Dr. O’Donohue: Why Courts Constrain Democratic Backsliding—or Enable It European Center for Populism Studies
  23. Prof. Turčalo: Serbia’s Student Movement Showed That the Western Balkans Are Not Condemned to Tyranny and Ethnonationalism European Center for Populism Studies
  24. The Dangerous Twilight of Social Democracy Law & Liberty
  25. Labor Law’s Illiberal Trajectory Law & Liberty
  26. The return of the shepherd: Leo XIV and the geopolitics of faith in Latin America Latinoamérica21

Written by Claude (Anthropic), based on 45 recent headlines and excerpts in this section, Nov 11. AI analysis can misread or miss things: the numbers link to the original reporting, which is the authority.