Ideologies around the world: analysis of 17 November 2026

Back to the Chronology · Current news in this section

Photo from Bernie Sanders says he won’t support Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader, NBC News

Analysis

National-populist contestation of the liberal order reaches the core of European security policy as Le Pen pledges to end Ukraine aid, while liberal-centrist governments in Canada and Germany try to hedge against both Moscow and an unpredictable Washington.

The week's items show the liberal international order being contested simultaneously from several directions: a national-conservative frontrunner in France proposes cutting Ukraine's financing 3, Germany's Christian-democratic chancellor warns Washington against 'alignment with Moscow' 12, and Canada's liberal prime minister openly uses Chinese investment as leverage in trade talks with the Trump administration 724. On the left, Vietnam's communist party pursues a remarkably ideology-agnostic party diplomacy, signing with Japan's conservative LDP 2 while deepening ties with Cuba and the Japanese Communist Party 914 and hosting Chile's right-wing president 5. In the Americas, left-populist and right-libertarian governments are reshaping institutions from opposite ends: Mamdani disbands a protest-policing unit in New York 419, while Milei pushes to suspend primaries and squeezes universities in Argentina 2836. Contestation over judicial independence and lustration in Poland and Serbia 344144 shows that the repair of captured institutions is as politically fraught as their capture.

Key developments

  • Le Pen makes Ukraine aid a wedge issue. Marine Le Pen, leading polls for France's April 2027 presidential election, says she would end financial aid to Ukraine if elected, and the Ukraine-Russia question has become a central campaign cleavage [3]. This positions the national-conservative right against the European consensus Merz articulates in Berlin [12] and Carney reiterates on Europe's security architecture [10]; it is the clearest case this week of a populist radical-right party translating sovereigntist nationalism into a concrete foreign-policy pledge rather than mere rhetoric. 3121032
  • Christian-democratic Germany positions against a US-Russia deal. Chancellor Merz said Germany had 'guaranteed' a seat at upcoming Ukraine peace talks and cautioned Washington against a 'second Anchorage moment' and alignment with Moscow [12]. This is a liberal-conservative government defending the Atlanticist order against its own senior ally's drift, which, read alongside Carney's insistence that only Europeans and NATO decide Europe's security architecture [10], suggests European mainstream conservatives and liberals are converging on strategic autonomy as a hedge rather than a doctrine. 121035
  • Carney's China hedge against Trump. Ahead of APEC, Carney said Canada could work with Chinese automakers if US trade talks fail, declining to deny this was leverage [7][24], and held sidelines meetings with Vietnam's communist leadership [6][8] while Sheinbaum travelled to Shenzhen for the same summit [21]. For a liberal centrist government this is a departure from the alliance-first orthodoxy of the pre-Trump era: economic nationalism in Washington is pushing middle powers towards multi-alignment, blurring the ideological line between the 'liberal' and 'authoritarian' camps in trade. 7246821
  • Vietnam's omnidirectional party diplomacy. The Communist Party of Vietnam signed a cooperation memorandum with Japan's governing LDP [2], met the Japanese Communist Party [14], sent a delegation to Cuba [9], attended a 'Left and the Contemporary World' symposium in Cyprus [11], and received Chile's right-wing president Kast at Ho Chi Minh's tribute [5]. The pattern shows a ruling communist party using party-to-party channels across the ideological spectrum as instruments of state legitimacy and hedging, with communism functioning as regime identity rather than as an internationalist programme. 2149115
  • Mamdani versus Milei: institutional remaking from left and right. New York's mayor Zohram Mamdani disbanded the NYPD Strategic Response Group criticised for excessive force at protests, replacing it with a community safety division [4][19], while Argentina's Milei is racing to suspend open primaries, pass the 2027 budget and reform the central bank's charter [28], having already cut university budgets by more than a fifth in real terms since 2023 [36]. Both are anti-establishment executives using executive and legislative tools to reshape the state in line with ideology, democratic socialism in one case and libertarian 'chainsaw' austerity in the other; the asymmetry is that Milei's changes touch electoral rules, which is where populist governance becomes 41928361
  • Judicial contestation in Brazil and Poland. Brazil's Justice de Moraes barred three visits to Jair Bolsonaro as party-political activity [30], while in Poland the acting president of the Constitutional Tribunal suspended two judges in a move its defenders say complies with European standards but which has generated 'considerable controversy' [34]. Both illustrate the dilemma of militant democracy: courts constraining a convicted or captured actor are read by their supporters as rule of law and by opponents as judicial politicisation, and the legitimacy of the remedy depends on the audience. 30344144

The ideologies this week

  • Nationalism and the radical right. National-conservative sovereigntism is ascendant in France, with Le Pen leading polls on a platform of ending Ukraine aid [3] against the historical backdrop of the French far right traced in a new study [32]. Ethno-nationalism also surfaced at an EU enlargement concert through a Serbian song claiming Kosovo [15], and in the 'moral purification' controversy on Rhodes [39]; the manosphere items point to a cultural reactionary current adjacent to but not identical with the political far right [16][17]. 332153916
  • Liberalism and the liberal international order. Liberal centrists Carney and Merz defend the rules-based order against Russia [10][12] but hedge against Washington through China trade options [7][24], showing liberalism's custodians adapting rather than retreating. The order's institutional underpinnings are simultaneously disputed in the Israel-France row over banning Mélenchon [13] and in debates over EU mutual-assistance obligations [35]. 101272413
  • Socialism and social democracy. The democratic-socialist left governs in New York, where Mamdani's disbanding of a protest-policing unit prioritises civil liberties over public-order orthodoxy [4][19], while Sanders' refusal to back Schumer signals the Democratic left contesting establishment leadership [1]. In Latin America, Lula's re-election is described by Uruguay's Orsi as 'fundamental' for Mercosur [20], and the intellectual left continues to theorise capitalism as crisis-prone [29]. 41912029
  • Communism. Vietnam's ruling party shows communism as state identity rather than programme, signing with Japan's conservative LDP [2], meeting Canada, Rwanda and Armenia [6], deepening ties with Cuba [9] and hosting Chile's right-wing Kast [5]. A possible Putin-Kim meeting at APEC in China [18] underscores that the remaining Leninist states function as a geopolitical bloc more than an ideological one. 269514
  • Libertarian capitalism and neoliberalism. Milei's Argentina is the live case: suspending primaries, reforming the central bank and passing an austerity budget [28] while university funding falls from 0.72% to about 0.53% of GDP [36]. The free-market intellectual front fights state-interventionist economics in the UK [45], while the Labour government's decision to end Palantir's NHS contract in 2029 shows a social-democratic state cautiously reasserting control over data infrastructure [22]. 28364522
  • Political Islam. Trump floated a blanket Muslim Brotherhood terror designation and said CAIR is being watched, without listing either [26], which if enacted would treat a transnational Islamist movement as a unitary terrorist actor. In Yemen, the Islamist Houthi movement makes steady gains as Saudi-allied forces redeploy [27], and Syria's new authorities are detaining Somali women and children removed from Roj camp [25], showing the post-ISIS management problem persisting. 262725

By region

  • Latin America. The region displays ideological pluralism without polarised bloc rivalry: Orsi praises ties with both Milei and Lula [20], Kast visits communist Vietnam [5], and Sheinbaum attends APEC in China [21]. The contested cases are institutional: Milei's push to suspend primaries and squeeze universities [28][36], and Brazil's court restricting Bolsonaro's political contacts [30]. 205212836
  • North America. Canada's liberal government hedges between Washington and Beijing [7][24], while US politics shows the left challenging Democratic leadership [1], a democratic-socialist mayor remaking policing [4][19], a Florida anti-DEI law producing unintended effects on a St Patrick's parade [23], and anticipated 'hardball' politics after the midterms [40]. Trump's Brotherhood remarks signal the national-conservative right's continued securitisation of political Islam [26]. 7241419
  • Europe. Le Pen's Ukraine aid pledge [3] and Merz's warning to Washington [12] frame the continent's security debate, while Serbia's post-electoral transition confronts lustration dilemmas [41][42][44] and Poland's judiciary repair stirs controversy [34]. The Kosovo song incident in Brussels shows enlargement still entangled with unresolved nationalism [15], and the Mélenchon ban row links French domestic politics to Israel [13]. 312414244
  • East Asia. Vietnam's party diplomacy spans Japan's LDP and JCP, Cuba and Chile [2][14][9][5], while APEC in China draws Carney, Sheinbaum and possibly Putin and Kim [21][18]. The region functions as the hub where liberal middle powers and Leninist states transact pragmatically rather than ideologically. 2149521
  • Middle East. Houthi gains and Saudi redeployment in Yemen [27], Syria's handling of Roj camp detainees [25], Israel's ban on Mélenchon [13] and warnings that Netanyahu's removal could trigger violence [43] show political Islam and right-wing nationalism shaping a region where liberal institutions are weak. Tunisian populism's conspiracy narratives illustrate how 'the other' is constructed discursively [31]. 2725134331
  • Africa. Africa appears only indirectly: Rwanda's Kagame among To Lam's Phnom Penh meetings [6], and Somali nationals facing deportation from Syria [25]. The items offer no basis for ideological claims about African domestic politics this week. 625

Themes

  • Hedging replaces alignment among liberal middle powers. Canada, Mexico and Germany each respond to US unpredictability not by abandoning the liberal order but by diversifying: Chinese automakers as leverage [7][24], APEC engagement in Shenzhen [21], and insistence on a European seat at peace talks [12][10]. The liberal international order is thus being contested from within by its own custodians' pragmatism as much as by populists. 724211210
  • Populism as a thin ideology attaching to different hosts. The week shows populist anti-establishment claims carried by nationalism in France [3], libertarian economics in Argentina [28][36], democratic socialism in New York [4][19] and student-led civic mobilisation in Serbia [41][42], with Tunisian populism relying on conspiracy narratives about 'the other' [31]. What unites them is the people-versus-elite frame; what divides them is the host ideology that determines policy content. 32836419
  • Repair after capture is contested as much as capture. Debates over lustration in post-Vučić Serbia [41][44] and over the legality of suspending judges in Poland [34] show that restoring liberal institutions requires actions that themselves look majoritarian or extra-legal. The risk flagged for Serbia, that former rulers return without accountability, mirrors the 2000 precedent noted by the same commentators [44]. 414434

Analytical lenses

  • Populism as a thin-centred ideology. Treating populism as a people-versus-elite frame that attaches to host ideologies explains why Le Pen's nationalism [3], Milei's libertarianism [28][36], Mamdani's socialism [4][19] and Serbia's student movement [42] all share anti-establishment legitimation while producing opposite policies. The lens misses the degree to which incumbents like Milei and Mamdani become the establishment themselves, and it says little about non-populist contestation such as Carney's hedging [7]. 32836419
  • Hedging and multi-alignment in middle-power foreign policy. The concept of hedging, maintaining options with rival great powers rather than balancing or bandwagoning, captures Carney's Chinese-automaker leverage [7][24], Sheinbaum's APEC trip [21], Merz's insistence on a European seat [12] and Vietnam's cross-spectrum party ties [2][14][9]. It explains the erosion of ideological bloc discipline but underplays domestic-political drivers such as Le Pen's electoral incentives [3] and the limits set by alliance treaty obligations [35]. 72421122
  • Militant democracy and democratic backsliding. The militant-democracy idea, that liberal orders may restrict actors who threaten them, illuminates de Moraes barring Bolsonaro's political visits [30], Poland's suspension of judges [34] and Serbian calls for lustration [41][44], as well as France's and Israel's reciprocal entry bans [13]. What it misses is the legitimacy problem: each measure is read by one camp as repair and by the other as capture, and the lens offers no neutral criterion for distinguishing them. 3034414413

What to watch

  • Whether Le Pen's rivals in the 2027 French race converge on or contest her Ukraine aid pledge, since this will indicate whether sovereigntist foreign policy is becoming mainstream in France [3]. 332
  • The outcome of Canada-US trade talks at and after APEC, which will show whether Carney's Chinese-automaker option was leverage or a real pivot [7][24][21]. 72421
  • Whether Argentina's Congress suspends the PASO primaries before year-end, a change to electoral rules that would test the limits of Milei's legislative coalition and of democratic safeguards [28]. 2836
  • Whether Trump proceeds from saying a blanket Muslim Brotherhood designation 'could happen' to an actual listing, with implications for US civil-society groups and Middle East partners [26]. 2627
Stories this analysis is based on (38)
  1. Bernie Sanders says he won’t support Chuck Schumer for Senate majority leader NBC News
  2. CPV, Japan's LDP sign cooperation memorandum Nhân Dân (Vietnamese state media)
  3. Le Pen wants to end Ukraine financial aid if elected The Kyiv Independent
  4. Mamdani disbands controversial NYPD unit accused of using excessive force The Guardian US
  5. Chilean President Jose Antonio Kast pays tribute to late President Ho Chi Minh Viet Nam News (state-run daily)
  6. Party General Secretary, President To Lam meets with leaders of Canada, Rwanda, Armenia, Andorra in Phnom Penh Nhân Dân (Vietnamese state media)
  7. Canada could work with Chinese automakers if US trade talks fail, says Carney The Guardian China
  8. PM meets with Brazilian, Canadian leaders on 49th ASEAN Summit sidelines Viet Nam News (state-run daily)
  9. Viet Nam, Cuba step up cooperation between Party agencies Nhân Dân (Vietnamese state media)
  10. Russia can not determine Europe's security architecture – Carney Ukrinform
  11. Viet Nam attends int'l symposium on 'The Left and the Contemporary World' in Cyprus Nhân Dân (Vietnamese state media)
  12. Merz Says Germany ‘Guaranteed’ a Seat at Ukraine Peace Talks Kyiv Post
  13. France slams Israel’s ‘demagogic’ ban on opposition leader Melenchon Al Jazeera
  14. Top leader meets Chairman of JCP Central Committee Nhân Dân (Vietnamese state media)
  15. Serbian Nationalist Song Sparks Outrage At EU Unity Concert RFE/RL
  16. In Get Huge, the manosphere is here to make friends — with deadly consequences The Verge
  17. Mamdani to disband NYPD unit deployed at Columbia protests Al Jazeera
  18. Orsi praises “excellent” ties with Milei and Lula’s re-election ahead of the Mercosur summit MercoPress
  19. Sheinbaum lands in Shenzhen on a commercial flight, then heads straight to tacos with Mexicans living in China Mexico News Daily
  20. Ministers to end Palantir’s contract with NHS in England in 2029 The Guardian UK Politics
  21. Canada could turn to Chinese automakers without US deal: Carney The Hill
  22. Somali Women and Children From Roj Camp Held in Damascus New Lines Magazine
  23. Trump Eyes Wider Brotherhood Terror Listing The Rio Times
  24. Saudi Arabia challenged by Yemeni allies over ceding ground to Houthis The Guardian Yemen
  25. Milei’s government races to suspend primaries and pass the budget before year-end MercoPress
  26. Anwar Shaikh Gave Us an Emancipatory Economics Jacobin (socialist)
  27. Supreme Court Judge Blocks Bolsonaro Visits The Rio Times
  28. Conspiracy Narratives and the Discursive Identity of ‘the Other’ in Tunisian Political Populism European Center for Populism Studies
  29. Shadow Casting: A Review of Enda O’Doherty’s The Dark Side of France Illiberalism Studies Program (GWU)
  30. Poland’s Captured Judiciary and the Challenges of Repair Verfassungsblog
  31. Die Reichweite der europäischen Beistandspflicht Verfassungsblog
  32. Resisting the Chainsaw Verfassungsblog
  33. The Hood on Rhodes and the Politics of Moral Purification European Center for Populism Studies
  34. Prof. Spasojević: Without Lustration and Accountability, Serbia’s Former Rulers Will Return European Center for Populism Studies
  35. Andrej Ševo: Serbia’s Students Made Democracy Cool Again European Center for Populism Studies
  36. Prof. Bernard Avishai Warns: Netanyahu’s Removal Could Trigger Greater Political Violence European Center for Populism Studies
  37. Prof. Bieber: Serbia Must Avoid the Mistakes That Allowed Authoritarianism to Return After 2000 European Center for Populism Studies
  38. Do we really want malaria back in Bristol? Adam Smith Institute (free-market)

Written by Claude Fable 5.1 (Anthropic), based on 45 recent headlines and excerpts in this section, 3d ago. AI analysis can misread or miss things: the numbers link to the original reporting, which is the authority.