Neoliberalism and its critics: analysis of 11 November 2026

Back to the Chronology · Current news in this section

Photo from Compassion is the antidote to the politics of cruelty | Letters, The Guardian US Politics

Analysis

Pope Leo XIV's challenge to Milei in Argentina puts austerity at the centre of this week's debate on neoliberalism, from Brazil to New York.

The biggest neoliberalism story this week is Pope Leo XIV's visit to a divided Argentina. He delivered a veiled rebuke of President Milei's austerity and challenged his vision for the economy, while calling for unity. Austerity is also described as the central conflict in Brazilian politics. In the US, writers ask how New York became so unequal and whether Democrats should drop growth as a goal. Market reform is spreading in unexpected places: Cuba has begun privatising its tourism industry and beaches. Analysts also ask what the world economy looks like after Trump, and whether Poland's growth model is a safe bet.

Key developments

  • The Pope and Milei. Pope Leo XIV delivered a veiled rebuke of Milei's austerity and challenged his economic vision during a visit to a divided Argentina, with calls for national unity. 1456
  • Austerity in Brazil. Austerity is now described as the central conflict in Brazilian politics after Lula's re-election. 11
  • Inequality in the US. Writers trace how New York became so unequal and argue that Democrats should forget growth as their organising goal. 310
  • Cuba's privatisation. Cuba has begun privatising parts of its tourism industry and beaches, a market reform under economic pressure. 8
  • After Trump. Commentators look at the global economy after Trump and at Poland as a growth success. 913

Debates over the market and the state

  • Libertarian austerity. Milei's programme remains the boldest neoliberal experiment in the region. 4
  • Catholic social critique. The Pope challenges markets in the name of the common good. 16
  • Post-growth left. Some writers ask Democrats to drop growth in favour of distribution. 103

Themes

  • Moral critiques of the market. The Pope and letter writers frame austerity as a 'politics of cruelty', a moral rather than technical critique. 12
  • Reform beyond the West. From Cuba's privatisation to China's shift from Maoism to the Chinese Dream, market logic spreads under socialist labels. 87

By region

  • Latin America. Argentina's austerity, Brazil's fiscal fight and Cuba's privatisation. 4118
  • North America. Inequality in New York and the growth debate. 310
  • Europe. Poland's growth story. 13

Analytical lenses

  • Embedded liberalism. Markets need social protection to stay legitimate, which explains resistance to Milei's cuts. It misses why Argentine voters elected Milei after years of crisis. 15
  • Policy diffusion. Market reforms travel even to socialist states like Cuba under pressure. This explains Cuba's moves; it underplays the state's continuing control. 8

What to watch

  • Milei's response to the Pope's critique. 4
  • How far Cuba's privatisation goes. 8
Stories this analysis is based on (12)
  1. Pope delivers veiled rebuke of Milei's austerity measures BBC Latin America
  2. Compassion is the antidote to the politics of cruelty | Letters The Guardian US Politics
  3. How Did New York Become So Unequal? The Nation (progressive)
  4. Pope Leo challenges Milei's vision for Argentina's economy Buenos Aires Times
  5. Pope Leo takes Milei to task as he visits divided Argentina Inquirer Global Nation
  6. Calls for unity as Pope Leo visits divided Argentina Buenos Aires Times
  7. Xi Jinping’s Chinese Dream Has Replaced the Maoist Credo Jacobin (socialist)
  8. Cuba Begins to Privatize its Tourism Industry and Beaches Havana Times
  9. The world after Trump UnHerd
  10. Why Democrats should forget growth UnHerd
  11. Austerity Is Now the Central Conflict in Brazilian Politics Jacobin (socialist)
  12. I'm betting on Poland Adam Smith Institute (free-market)

Written by Claude (Anthropic), based on 13 recent headlines and excerpts in this section, Nov 11. AI analysis can misread or miss things: the numbers link to the original reporting, which is the authority.