South China Sea: analysis of 11 November 2026
Back to the Chronology · Current news in this section

Analysis
Before the ASEAN summit it hosts, Manila tries to calm tensions with Beijing and finish a code of conduct, while it builds surveillance with US help and weighs a second legal case.
The Philippines dominates this week's South China Sea coverage as it prepares to host the ASEAN summit. Finishing a Code of Conduct is one of President Marcos's main goals, the foreign ministry calls diplomacy its main tool, and Manila is trying to soften its tone. Chinese Premier Li Qiang, not Xi, is expected to attend. Domestic critics accuse the foreign ministry of trying to monopolise the China debate. Analysts doubt a softer tone will ease tensions, and say Manila is considering a second legal case against Beijing. At the same time, the Philippine Coast Guard is adding US-supplied surveillance planes, and commentators urge closer US–Vietnam defence ties. Beyond the sea itself, China's growing naval and air reach is offsetting its Malacca dilemma, and analysts ask whether PLA drills rehearse keeping US forces out of a Taiwan conflict.
Essay
Law, power and the regional order
The South China Sea is where three ideas of order meet. The first is international law: the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea and the 2016 arbitral award, which rejected China's 'nine-dash line' claims in its case with the Philippines. The second is power: China's growing navy, coast guard and maritime militia, which create facts on the water. The third is regional diplomacy: ASEAN's long effort to agree a Code of Conduct with China. This week's news touches all three.
The Philippines, preparing to host the ASEAN summit, says completing the Code of Conduct is one of President Marcos's key goals 1, and its foreign ministry calls diplomacy its 'primary tool' in managing disputes 13. Yet Manila is also weighing a second legal case against Beijing 15, a reminder that law remains its strongest weapon against a stronger neighbour.
The Philippine dilemma
Manila's strategy combines softer rhetoric with harder capabilities. It is trying to ease tensions before the summit 19, but analysts doubt that a softer tone will change Beijing's behaviour 7. At the same time, the coast guard is strengthening its surveillance with turboprop aircraft supplied by the United States 3. Domestic politics complicates the picture: Senator De Lima accuses the foreign ministry of trying to monopolise the China debate 4, Defence Secretary Teodoro has criticised China's 'threat of censorship' 16, and Rappler describes discord seeping through the fissures 12.
This is a classic hedging pattern for a smaller claimant: talk to Beijing, build a legal record, and rely on a powerful ally for capability, without letting any of these become the whole strategy.
Viet Nam and the other claimants
Viet Nam, the other most active claimant, follows a similar but quieter path. Commentators call for elevating US–Viet Nam defence ties for regional stability 8, which would add to Hanoi's deepening links with Japan and its own expansion of outposts in the Spratlys. Indonesia is urged to modernise its foreign policy 11, and a new trilateral partnership is discussed among regional states 5.
For Viet Nam the challenge is to defend its claims without provoking China or appearing to join a US-led bloc, which would breach its 'four noes' policy. Its approach combines island building, legal argument, diplomacy through ASEAN, and partnerships with Japan, India and the US.
China's reach
China's position rests on its growing ability to operate far from its coast. Analysts describe how its naval and air reach is offsetting the 'Malacca dilemma', its vulnerability to a blockade of the strait through which much of its energy passes 17. The PLA appears to be rehearsing operations to keep US forces out of a Taiwan conflict 9, and China is fast-tracking a mobile ICBM to strengthen its second-strike capability 2. Researchers have built an index of China's maritime power projection across six strategic regions 20.
These developments mean the South China Sea is not only a territorial dispute but part of a broader military balance between China and the US, linked to Taiwan and nuclear deterrence.
What the ASEAN summit can and cannot do
The ASEAN summit in Manila, which Chinese Premier Li Qiang rather than Xi Jinping is expected to attend 18, is a test of regional diplomacy. A Code of Conduct would be a symbolic achievement, but negotiations have run for more than two decades, and China resists a binding text that would limit its activities. Research on state messaging in crises shows that how governments frame incidents can push either towards escalation or restraint 21.
The most likely outcome is continued management rather than resolution: incremental agreements, more coast guard encounters, and legal and diplomatic pressure from the smaller claimants. The rules-based order in the South China Sea survives not because it is enforced, but because the smaller states keep invoking it.
Key developments
- A Code of Conduct push. Malacañang says completing the Code of Conduct is one of Marcos's key goals, and analysts call the ASEAN summit 'Manila's moment'. Li Qiang, rather than Xi, is expected in the Philippines. 1618
- A softer tone from Manila. The foreign ministry says diplomacy is the primary tool for managing disputes and Manila is easing tensions before the summit, but SCMP analysis doubts this will calm Beijing. 13197
- Domestic dissent. Senator De Lima says the foreign ministry is trying to monopolise the China debate, and Defence Secretary Teodoro criticised China's 'threat of censorship', showing divisions in Manila. 41612
- Legal and surveillance options. Manila is weighing a second legal case against Beijing, and the Coast Guard is boosting surveillance with turboprop planes from the US. 153
- Partners in the region. Commentators call for stronger US–Vietnam defence ties and a new trilateral partnership, and Indonesia is urged to modernise its foreign policy. 8511
- China's reach. China's naval and air power is offsetting its Malacca dilemma, the PLA may be rehearsing operations to keep US forces from a Taiwan conflict, and Beijing is fast-tracking a mobile ICBM. 1792
Themes
- Hedging between talks and deterrence. Manila combines diplomacy and a softer tone with US surveillance aid and legal pressure, a hedge typical of smaller claimants. 13315
- Measuring maritime power. Researchers build indices of China's maritime projection across six regions and study how state messaging shapes escalation and restraint in crises. 2021
Stories this analysis is based on (19)
- ‘Sea code completion one of Marcos’ key goals’ The Manila Times
- China fast-tracks mobile ICBM to lock down second-strike edge Asia Times
- Philippine Coast Guard Bolsters Surveillance With Turboprop Planes From U.S. Eurasia Review
- DFA statement looks like attempt to monopolize China discourse – De Lima Inquirer Global Nation
- A New Trilateral Partnership – OpEd Eurasia Review
- ASEAN’s Manila Moment – OpEd Eurasia Review
- Why Manila’s call for softer tone will not ease South China Sea tensions with Beijing SCMP China
- Elevating US-Vietnam defense ties for regional stability Asia Times
- Is the PLA rehearsing operations to keep US forces out of a Taiwan conflict? SCMP China
- Modernizing Indonesia’s Foreign Policy – OpEd Eurasia Review
- Philippines’ West PH Sea, China discord seeps through fissures Rappler
- DFA: Diplomacy is PH’s primary tool in managing disputes with China Inquirer Global Nation
- Manila weighs second South China Sea legal case against Beijing: analyst SCMP China
- Gibo slams China’s ‘Threat of Censorship’ Inquirer Global Nation
- How China’s Naval-Air Reach Is Offsetting the Malacca Dilemma The Diplomat
- No Xi, but Li of China expected in PH-hosted Asean summit Inquirer Global Nation
- Philippines tries to ease tensions with China as ASEAN Summit nears Rappler
- Quantifying Maritime Power: A Systematic Index of China’s Maritime Projection in Six Strategic Regions Journal articles (OpenAlex)
- Scripts of Escalation and Restraint: State Messaging and Public Opinion in International Crises Journal articles (OpenAlex)
Written by Claude (Anthropic), based on 21 recent headlines and excerpts in this section, Nov 11. AI analysis can misread or miss things: the numbers link to the original reporting, which is the authority.