Between Resistance and Reproduction: The Brazilian Supreme Court Under Authoritarian Pressure
Abstract For upholding evidence-based policymaking during the COVID-19 crisis and prosecuting antidemocratic actors, the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court (STF) has been widely portrayed as a bulwark of democracy. This article challenges this celebratory narrative by examining the Court’s jurisprudence through the lens of fundamental rights. It argues that the STF’s democratic protagonism coexists with a pattern of ambivalent adjudication in which boldness in defending…