The problem of mutual defeat in Strong Phenomenal Conservatism
Abstract Strong Phenomenal Conservatism, as defended by Michael Huemer, says that having an appearance that p is a necessary and sufficient condition for having a justified belief that p in the absence of defeaters. I argue that the no-defeater condition is problematic in Strong Phenomenal Conservatism because it leads to the problem of mutual defeat due to conflicting appearances, a problem that becomes especially clear with optical illusions. I show that the problem of…