Handshakes Without Headway
Welcome to The Adversarial. Every other week, we’ll provide you with expert analysis on America’s greatest challengers: China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, and jihadists.
177 research items
Journal articles, academic blogs, think-tank reports and papers in this section, newest first. Back to the news.
Welcome to The Adversarial. Every other week, we’ll provide you with expert analysis on America’s greatest challengers: China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, and jihadists.

Researchers often examine online violent extremism through the content, accounts, and interactions visible on individual digital platforms. This approach helps identify extremist material and enforce platform rules, but offers only a partial view of how online activity develops over time. Past research has already documented movement between mainstream platforms and more private or encrypted spaces. The question is therefore not

Across global digital subcultures, extremist networks are increasingly weaponising edgy internet humour and memes to spread covert propaganda. In the West, the far-right extremist movement has successfully exploited the culture of shitposting and internet memes to normalise hate speech in the public sphere. This practice of meme hijacking and the exploitation of pop culture has also been used by ISIS
The election of Abdul El-Sayed and other Muslim officeholders has stirred fears of an Islamist takeover. But their records tell a different story. Our democracy can survive any group’s participation. Source
Abstract This article examines how evidential authority is textually constructed in contemporary Saudi legal judgments. Instead of treating evidentiality as a narrowly grammatical category, it develops a discourse-level account of how Arabic legal judgments encode source, reliability, institutional standing, and normative force through citation, attribution, and genre sequencing. The corpus comprises Volume 2 of the Collection of Judicial Rulings 1435 H, including 90 case…
Executive Summary The concept of asylum is not modern: it has deep historical and religious roots that far predate modern legal frameworks. This paper traces that lineage from the Ancient Near East and classical antiquity through Jewish, Christian, and Islamic traditions, showing how each conveys a shared duty to welcome the stranger. In the contemporary world, asylum is legally established under the 1951 Geneva Convention and international refugee law, with primary…
This article examines how Zeteo’s We’re Not Kidding narrates, contests, and ethically frames war through long-form conversation. Drawing on close analysis of 17 purposively selected episodes, it asks how the podcast’s form, humour, guest heterogeneity, and evidentiary debate shape media practice during the Gaza war that began in October 2023, which participants describe as genocidal. Four practices organize the analysis: meta-journalistic critique, debunking as evidentiary…
This article examines how dialogue with jihadist groups in Mali and Niger operates as both a mechanism of governance and a site of ideological translation. It explores how competing Islamic repertoires, reformist-Salafi and Sufi-Maliki, are localised, resisted or refracted through Sahelian religious and socio-political orders. Drawing on ethnographic research, it introduces transactional governance to capture how insurgencies impose, then bargain over, zakāt, sharīʿa-based…
Welcome to The Adversarial. Every other week, we’ll provide you with expert analysis on America’s greatest challengers: China, Russia, Iran, North Korea, and jihadists.
The influence of Islamic law on mosque architecture is a growing field of study that remains in its infancy. Existing studies often focus on the historicity, ornamentation, and architectural significance of mosques and their constituent parts, such as miḥrāb (imām’s prayer niche). Although the legal materials concerning the elevation of the imām have previously been discussed, their possible relevance to explaining the architectural configuration of the miḥrāb has not, to…
Understanding long-term land-use change is essential for interpreting Mediterranean cultural landscapes. This study reconstructs the landscape and agroecosystem dynamics of the former royal estate of Monteagudo-Cabezo de Torres (Murcia, SE Spain) from the 12th century to the present. We integrated archaeobotanical remains, historical documentation, radiocarbon dating and floristic inventories (19th century-2026), explicitly accounting for sampling biases in historical…
IMPACTThis article discusses how state Islamic universities in Indonesia translated global risk management mandates into their local religious governance frameworks. Indonesia's experience highlights the importance of cultural translation and the need to align secular corporate metrics with deeply rooted institutional values. The article addresses public sector managers, university administrators and policy-makers involved in higher education governance and risk management…
This paper presents a preliminary scoping study of seven schools that are seeking to renew K-12 education from an Islamic worldview. It offers a cursory analysis of the discourse of these schools as they define their understandings of education and the human person in relation to renewal, and attempt to enact these through philosophies, pedagogies, and practices. It considers the decolonial nature of both the discourse and practices adopted by the schools, as well as the…
The expansion of State Islamic Universities (PTKIN) in Indonesian urban areas has reshaped spatial relations among campuses, residential neighborhoods, and surrounding Islamic boarding schools (pesantren). However, studies integrating Islamic campuses and pesantren within a socio-spatial network framework remain limited. This study examines the socio-spatial network connecting UIN Walisongo Campus and nearby pesantren, with the campus as the primary node, Jl. Prof. Hamka as…
The Rohingya crisis has attracted significant humanitarian and media attention. However, limited research has examined how Islamic media report refugee issues through religious journalism frameworks. This study examines humanitarian witnessing in Indonesian Islamic media during the Rohingya crisis. Drawing on the perspective of Daʿwa Journalism, it analyzes 425 news articles published by NU Online, Suara Muhammadiyah, and Republika between 2014 and 2024. The study employs…
From eastern Libya’s ratification of the 2019 Turkey-Libya maritime agreement reshaping East Med and provoking opposition from Greece and the US, to Russia’s expanding footprint across Africa and China’s growing role in the continent’s industrial and energy sectors.
Purpose This study examines the association between graduates' retrospective assessments of an experiential learning curriculum and their self-reported perceived competitiveness, while separately describing employment relevance and monthly income. The study treats the competence-wage paradox as a descriptive and interpretive pattern rather than an empirically tested wage relationship. Design/methodology/approach A quantitative, cross-sectional ex post facto design was…
This article investigates whether the rise of political Islam under the Adalet ve Kalkınma Partisi (AKP; Justice and Development Party) has given rise to a corresponding process of religious strengthening among Jewish minorities in Turkey. The article argues that it has not done so. On the basis of a historical analysis and qualitative interviews, the study reveals that the Islamization of public life has reinforced longstanding patterns of civic secularism and limited…
ABSTRACT Daryush Shayegan (1935–2018), a major yet underrecognized Iranian philosopher, offers a compelling framework for rethinking the Islamic revolution and broader religious‐political dynamics. This article introduces his thought to Anglophone audiences, challenging traditional interpretations of the 1979 revolution. Rather than a return to tradition, Shayegan views it as a modern event, in which religious symbols act as unconscious psychological defenses against change…
The increasing integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into religious knowledge production raises critical questions regarding religious authority, ethical agency, and the future of Islamic legal decision-making. This study examines how AI-generated responses to Islamic legal questions perform against epistemological, methodological, and ethical requirements traditionally associated with Islamic legal reasoning. Employing a qualitative, comparative, and interpretive…
Social work as a professional discipline has historically evolved alongside moral and religious traditions that emphasize compassion, justice, and collective responsibility. While the influence of Christian ethics on Western social work has been widely examined, Islamic welfare ethics remain comparatively underexplored within mainstream social work scholarship. This paper presents a conceptual and theoretical analysis of the intersections between professional social work and…
This article investigates the contested religious identities of Waraqah ibn Nawfal and the Negus of Abyssinia (Arabic: al-Najāshī) and argues that the Prophet Muḥammad’s engagement with both figures reflects a form of contextual inclusivism that transcends rigid confessional boundaries. Methodologically, the study combines hadith criticism, historical analysis, and contemporary theological reflection within the framework of contextual inclusive theology to reassess the…
Artificial intelligence (AI) is gaining increasing attention in elementary education, yet technological access alone may not determine whether students perceive AI as educationally valuable. This study examined students’ perceived benefits of AI for critical reading and the contributions of gender, digital-contextual conditions, AI readiness and learning support, and perceived technical barriers. A cross-sectional survey involving 857 fifth-grade students from 22 public…
This study examines how Islamic school principals in Ontario, Canada, discuss their leadership using frameworks of renewal and faith as the ultimate concern. Drawing on 11 in-depth interviews, the study finds these leaders define success in both academic and religious terms, driven by religious salvation, parental roles, and pastoral responsibility. Their motivation leads them to extend their efforts beyond conventional leadership toward students’ religious development. The…
This paper aims to present an overview of the pottery assemblage from a previously unknown rural settlement functioning during the Middle Islamic period (12th–15th centuries) at Khirbat es-Sār in relation to the regional context. The study of this assemblage involves traditional chrono-typological, as well as quantitative and petrographic analyses. In general, although the ceramic evidence from the Middle Islamic period is strongly rooted in the regional pottery traditions…
In 2018, Barak Mendelsohn wrote, “Bound to Fail: Transnational Jihadism and the Aggregation Problem,” where he argued that transnational jihadist groups like al-Qaeda and the Islamic State would continue failing to turn local victories into a lasting caliphate, allowing counterterrorism forces to contain them without costly U.S.-led interventions. Eight years later, we asked Barak to revisit his arguments.Image: Adam Jones/FlickrYour article opened with al-Baghdadi’s 2018…
This study compares the values of moderation, tolerance, and sustainable social peace in Islamic jurisprudence and international legal instruments. It examines their conceptual foundations, areas of agreement, and differences in legal and ethical approaches. Using descriptive, analytical, and comparative methods, the study reviews Islamic sources, relevant international declarations, and practical examples of peaceful coexistence. It also considers how digital media can…
John Updike’s Terrorist (2006) and Mohsin Hamid’s The Reluctant Fundamentalist (2007), authored by writers of distinctly different ethnic and cultural backgrounds, converge on the thematic terrain of post-9/11 anxieties and the complex psychological experiences of America’s multiracial population. The central protagonists, Ahmad in Terrorist and Changez in The Reluctant Fundamentalist are both Muslim men whose differing degrees of religious commitment intersect with shared…
Mainstream film studies on masculinity are still dominated by a Western paradigm that tends to emphasize secular rationality and competitive aggression, and thus often fail to explain the formation of the spiritual and ethical values underlying male identity in predominantly Muslim societies. To bridge this gap, this study examines the representation of Islamic masculinity in Islamic-themed films in Indonesia, Malaysia, and Brunei Darussalam. This was done to uncover the…
Between 2005 and 2013, Iran adapted its use of soft power in the Gulf region in response to tensions over its nuclear program and the Arab Spring. In Bahrain, Iran emphasized ideological and religious influence, focusing on political disenfranchisement and Shiite rights. However, this influence triggered a defensive securitization response from the Bahraini regime, supported by Saudi intervention. Conversely, Iran took a pragmatic approach toward Qatar, fostering political…