Zion without Africa: Messianic Nationalism and the Frazier–Herskovits Debate on African Religious Retention
Frazier held that slavery destroyed African religion's institutional substance; Herskovits held that African cultural traits survived and structured African American religious life. The dispute has been tested against the sector of Black Christianity presumed richest in “survivals”: ecstatic worship, spirituals, and conjure. This article argues the more decisive test case is the messianic-nationalist sects - the Black Hebrew Israelite and Ethiopianist movements of the…