Verfassungsblog

Recent stories from Verfassungsblog.

Verfassungsblog Wojciech Sadurski Geopolitics

What the Oath-Taking Opinion Really Means

Strict compliance with certain statutory rules, especially those enacted by the ancien régime deliberately to maintain its power even beyond an eventual electoral defeat, may result in the “perpetuation of an unacceptable status quo”, a condition which I had characterized, darkly, as a “Sisyphean democracy”. Nowhere is this condition more visible than in post-2023 Poland. A recent Opinion of the Venice Commission on the presidential oath-taking from newly elected judges of…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Sué González Hauck Geopolitics

Hauptsache bündnisfähig

Die Bündnisfähigkeit Deutschlands ist zu einem neuen, zentralen Verfassungsgut in der Rechtsprechung des Bundesverfassungsgerichts geworden. Deutlich wird das in einem Beschluss des Gerichts vom 3. Februar 2026. Ausgangspunkt für diesen Beschluss war die Verfassungsbeschwerde von Abed J., einem in Gaza lebenden Palästinenser, der mehrere Familienmitglieder bei israelischen Angriffen verloren hatte. Er wandte sich gegen zwei Genehmigungen für Waffenexporte nach Israel. Das…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Kim Lane Scheppele Geopolitics

Poland’s Captured Judiciary and the Challenges of Repair

On 30 October 2026, Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, acting President of Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal, temporarily suspended the two judges hitherto exercising the functions of President and Vice-President. Her actions have generated considerable controversy. In an earlier post, we defended the orders as complying with European and Polish law, and we also defended the lawfully elected judges’ efforts to restore the Constitutional Tribunal’s functioning and status as an…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Moritz von Rochow Geopolitics

Die Reichweite der europäischen Beistandspflicht

Stellen wir uns einmal vor, Deutschland ist einem Bündnispartner zum Beistand verpflichtet, der Bundestag verweigert aber die vorherige Zustimmung zum militärischen oder zivilen Beistand – kein unwahrscheinliches Szenario. Mit Blick auf die EU hat das Bundesverfassungsgericht festgestellt, dass auch die Europäische Union vertretbar als ein System gegenseitiger kollektiver Sicherheit angesehen werden könne. Wie konkret der wehrverfassungsrechtliche Parlamentsvorbehalt in der…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Nahuel Maisley Geopolitics

Resisting the Chainsaw

Since Javier Milei took office in December 2023, the budget of Argentina’s national universities has lost more than a fifth of its value in real terms. University funding has fallen from 0.72% to about 0.53% of GDP, and by May 2026, university salaries had lost more than a third of their purchasing power. These numbers reflect a hostility towards public universities that austerity alone does not explain. Milei, like many of his peers on the new right around the world, treats…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Alexandra Lorch Geopolitics

Ein neues Gesetz für gestern

Dass Bewerberinnen oft schlechter bewertet werden als männliche Mitbewerber, ist nichts Neues. Doch inzwischen treffen nicht mehr nur Personalverantwortliche diese Entscheidung, sondern algorithmische Systeme. So sperrte etwa ein Lieferdienst einem Schwarzen Fahrer den Zugang zu seinem Arbeitsaccount, weil die biometrische Identitätsprüfung ihn nicht erkannt hat – denn marginalisierte Gruppen sind in Datensätzen unterrepräsentiert, sodass die Gesichtserkennungssoftware…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Nadiv Mordechay Geopolitics

The Delegitimisation of the Arab Vote in Israel

Political uncertainty in Israel has intensified following inconclusive election results. Since the election, the political right has sought to delegitimise the unprecedented electoral success of Arab citizens, whose representatives secured 19 of the Knesset’s 120 seats. The right has united behind Netanyahu’s unprecedented "election-theft" campaign, portraying Arab participation in government as treasonous support for terrorism and Islamization. This delegitimisation effort…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Thiemo Lüeße Geopolitics

Hybride Kriegsführung oder subkutane Angriffe?

„Wir sind nicht im Krieg, aber wir sind auch nicht mehr im Frieden“ – diese Diagnose des deutschen Bundeskanzlers Friedrich Merz erfasst die aktuelle Sicherheitslage präziser als der inflationär verwendete Begriff der hybriden Kriegsführung. Deutschland sieht sich einer systematischen Kampagne zur gesellschaftlichen Destabilisierung gegenüber. Es handelt sich um subkutane Angriffe, die sich über die Absicht des Angreifers definieren und nicht über die eingesetzten Mittel…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Patrick Heinemann Geopolitics

Verteidigung im Schattenkrieg

Russland führt einen Schattenkrieg gegen die europäischen NATO-Staaten, allen voran Deutschland. Trotzdem ist die deutsche Staatsrechtslehre auf fundamentale Fragen, die sich bei der Verteidigung unseres politischen Gemeinwesens stellen, erstaunlich wenig vorbereitet. Der äußere Notstand kann aber nicht länger verdrängt werden. Notwendig ist insbesondere eine Klärung des Verteidigungsbegriffs gerade im Angesicht der Bedrohungen und Angriffe, die schon jetzt von Russland…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Luce deLire Geopolitics

Stonewall-Vibes in Berlin

Am 18. Oktober 2026 durchsuchten 38 Polizeikräfte das Gesundheits- und Gemeindezentrum „Casa Kuà“ in Berlin. Diese Razzia hat die queere Community weit über Berlin hinaus in Aufregung versetzt. Casa Kuà ist ein Gemeinschaftsort in Berlin für gegenseitige Unterstützung, Austausch, regelmäßige Treffen, Workshops. Casa Kuà leistet einen wichtigen Beitrag zur Schadensminderung für trans* Personen in einem diskriminierenden Gesundheitssystem. Statt trans*affirmative…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Priya S. Gupta Geopolitics

Claims to the City

I suppose property professors are always on the lookout for unconventional uses of land. My work examines the transformation of various cities under financial capitalism. City governments regulate land to attract real estate investors just as they make governance decisions as if they were financial actors and not representatives of the public. I’ve argued that investors and their partner real estate developers exercise agency in the city. This has left cities less prone to…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Peer Zumbansen Geopolitics

Tech Power’s Violence

As the lament swells around democratic crisis and the rise of the right, with populist moped-riders sweeping elections and traditional political parties left “shocked”, attention increasingly turns to the actual processes and spaces of political deliberation and their corrosion through social media and artificial intelligence (AI). Contentions around “too much screen time”, however, fall short of addressing both the significant place that social media holds in…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Carolina Alonso Bejarano Geopolitics

No One is Illegal on Stolen Land

In “My Hometown,” part of his Born in the U.S.A. album, Bruce Springsteen sings nostalgically about growing up in Freehold, his hometown, in the 1950s. What is striking about this song is that the same story could be told about thousands of towns in the country. Indeed, as a key site during the Revolutionary War and the inspiration for Springsteen’s 1985 classic, Freehold Borough is invested in its authenticity as an historic and “all-American” city. Drawing on this poetic…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Diego Platz Pereira Geopolitics

Brazil’s Democracy Tomorrow

A historic runoff election took place in Brazil last month. Lula da Silva defeated the far-right candidate Flávio Bolsonaro by nearly 4.4 million votes. The outcome of this election provides an opportunity to take stock of the resilience of Brazilian democracy and the challenges it continues to face. Its future urgently depends on stronger institutions and a strategic reduction of excessive decision-making powers concentrated in individual actors.

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Hendrik Simon Geopolitics

Sicherheitshalber für das Recht

„Wenn es ernst wird“, so lautet der Titel dieser Beitragsreihe. Ein Blick in die gegenwärtige Weltpolitik zeigt: Es ist längst ernst. In der Bundesrepublik wird über Kriegs- bzw. Verteidigungsfähigkeit debattiert, über Abschreckung und Aufrüstung, über Wehrdienst und Wehrpflicht. Zugleich gehen mit der Fokussierung auf Sicherheitslogik Gefahren einher: eine Militarisierung von Politik und Gesellschaft, in der Völker- und Verfassungsrecht potenziell zu einer lästigen…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Gábor Halmai Geopolitics

Democracy Put to the Test in Israel

The October 27 Knesset election appeared to produce a political deadlock in Israel, as neither the current governing coalition led by Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud party nor the parties making up the anti-Netanyahu camp managed to secure the 61 seats required for a parliamentary majority. Since Eisenkot and his allies explicitly identify themselves as Zionists, their readiness to enter into an alliance with Arab parties – the most obvious way out of the electoral deadlock…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Frederick Attenborough Geopolitics

Counter-Terrorism Law and Free Speech on Campus

A rare Equality Act 2010 challenge to a referral under Prevent, the UK’s counter-terrorism programme for identifying and responding to suspected signs of radicalisation, has ended with a County Court finding that a school unlawfully discriminated against a Muslim schoolboy. Although a first-instance decision, the ruling has important implications for universities. The case foregrounds a risk inherent in Prevent’s precautionary referral process that the lawful expression of…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Cristián Irarrázaval Zaldívar Geopolitics

What Isn’t Organised Crime?

The undeniable danger posed by real criminal organisations justifies offences so elastic that they fit almost any group of people, and whose invocation unlocks consequences bearing no proportion to the conduct. By punishing mere membership, these statutes create what Gerard Lynch called the crime of being a criminal. The vagueness is not a drafting failure. It is by design. A liberal criminal law – understood as one committed to constraining the state’s power to punish…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Lucia Leontiev Geopolitics

The Global East and the Promise of Reflexivity

In 1999, David Kennedy famously affirmed that “international law is different in different places”, a reality that practitioners and scholars around the world had already long experienced. From the Global South’s imperial critique and rejection of international law, to a religiously infused international law in the Arab World, or the recent acknowledgement of European international law as a regional law, one can argue that the “local” in international law is central to any…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Oumar Ba Geopolitics

Race, Empire, and the Liberal International Order

The complex set of international laws, rules, norms, and institutions that have shaped global governance since the end of World War II is now subject to an unprecedented set of challenges and reconfigurations. They all raise important questions about what the future may hold for this world order. Yet these debates miss a fundamental aspect about the foundations and predicates of the LIO.

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Anja Bossow Geopolitics

A Blue Wave’s Limits

If we can still believe the pollsters, Democrats are headed for a very good night next Tuesday. Across the United States, candidates running as Democrats are either leading or running even with their Republican opponents. That the president’s party loses ground in the midterms, often decisively, is one of the more reliable patterns in American politics. But if such a blue wave materializes, we should neither read it as voters’ repudiation of the Republican Party, nor as an…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Anja Bossow Geopolitics

Die Grenzen einer Blue Wave

Wenn man den Umfrageinstituten noch trauen darf, steht den Demokraten am kommenden Dienstag ein ziemlich guter Wahlabend bevor. Im ganzen Land liegen demokratische Kandidat:innen entweder vorn oder liefern sich mit ihren republikanischen Konkurrent:innen ein Kopf-an-Kopf-Rennen. Dass die Partei des Präsidenten bei den Midterms an Zustimmung verliert – oft sogar deutlich –, gehört zu den verlässlichsten Mustern der US-Politik. Eine solche „Blue Wave“ sollte aber weder als…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Rohit Sarma Geopolitics

Confluence Constitutionalism

What does a Bollywood soundtrack have to do with the future of constitutionalism? More than one might think. Just as Chutney music defies notions of cultural purity, constitutionalism has emerged from centuries of entanglement between Western and non-Western ideas. Challenging both Eurocentric histories and romanticised visions of an authentic indigenous past, the idea of confluence constitutionalism opens up a different path to decolonisation.

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Theunis Roux Geopolitics

Liberal Constitutionalism Beyond the West?

Globalisation has not simply involved the diffusion of a Western constitutional model. It has also involved the transformation of the tradition itself. Liberal constitutionalism is no longer the hegemonic global governance ideology or model it used to be. Rather, it can be understood as an evolving, interpretively open, experimentalist tradition. Starting from these premises, my book engages the five critiques set out above.

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Chris Hilson Geopolitics

Waiting or Pushing?

On 19 October 2026, the UK Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero agreed to the grant of consent by the Oil and Gas Authority for the Jackdaw gas field project under the Offshore Oil and Gas Exploration, Production, Unloading and Storage (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations 2020. The decision deserves close attention by climate and energy lawyers both for its compatibility with the remaining global carbon budget and for its treatment of scope 3…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Thomas Bustamante Geopolitics

Democratic Resistance in the Brazilian Elections

In one of the most dramatic elections in the history of Brazil, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva has achieved a victory against the far-right incumbent Flávio Bolsonaro, son of former president Jair Bolsonaro, who is now under house arrest following a conviction to more than twenty-seven years for a coup attempt in January 2023. Less than two days after the election results were announced, Flávio left the country to seek asylum in the United States, in defiance of a court order…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Bojan Spaić Geopolitics

Democratic Resistance in the Serbian Elections

On 25 October, the Student List won an absolute majority in Serbia's parliamentary election. Aleksandar Vučić conceded within minutes of the polls closing. The significance of this election goes beyond the composition of parliament and lies in what its result will allow Serbia to leave behind, since, like Poland and Hungary, Serbia is one of the states whose courts and other key institutions have been captured by the ruling party.

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Markus Leber Geopolitics

Geheimniskrämerei im Plenarsaal

Die CDU-Fraktion im Landtag von Sachsen-Anhalt hat angekündigt, sich bei der anstehenden Wahl eines Ministerpräsidenten nicht nur zu enthalten, sondern für die ersten beiden Wahlgänge den Sitzungssaal zu verlassen. Hintergrund dieses Manövers ist, dass die Wahl geheim stattfindet und es daher für einen einzelnen Abgeordneten keine Möglichkeit gibt, das eigene Abstimmungsverhalten zu belegen. Über die politische Weisheit und rechtliche Bewertung dieses Manövers wird…

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog David Dyzenhaus Geopolitics

Common Good Ideology Seeks to Colonize Canada

Common good constitutionalism is coming to Canada. The “Restoring the Foundations of Judicial Power” project, founded in 2025, transplants the arguments of Oxford’s Judicial Power Project into a legal order with an entrenched bill of rights. The aim of the project is the same: a world without pluralism, where law is merely the ruler’s fiat.

Read at Verfassungsblog

Verfassungsblog Pedro Marques Neto Geopolitics

The Legal Structure of the Incumbency Advantage

Imagine that you intend to run for president of the Republic, governor of a state, or mayor of a municipality. During the campaign, you can choose to run either as an ordinary candidate or as the current holder of the office you seek. Which option would you choose? The answer is intuitive: your chances of success are usually greater if you are running for reelection. This incumbency advantage is a well-known phenomenon. Less well known is the way electoral rules can…

Read at Verfassungsblog