Grey-zone coercion at sea: coast guards, militias and shoals

Grey-zone coercion at sea: coast guards, maritime militias, water cannon and ramming at disputed shoals, the law of the sea and the 2016 arbitral award, freedom-of-navigation operations, shadow fleets and undersea cables, from the news and journal research. Kept for a year as an archive.

Summary

58 news articles and 41 research items in this section, back to 24 November 2025. Browse the news ↓ Research ↓

0 stories from 0 publishers in the last 24 hours, 20 from 12 this week; 2 stories were covered by more than one newsroom.

Most mentioned in Grey-zone coercion at sea: coast guards, militias and shoals headlines, last 3 days: China 3Code 3Conduct 2

Most active this week: The Manila Times (6), The Kyiv Independent (3), Ukrainska Pravda (2), Eurasia Review (1). Built automatically from headlines; the top items are the stories the most newsrooms covered in the last three days.

Analysis

China's coast guard shadows Philippine resupply missions and Taiwan drives off 'maritime harassment', as the Philippines adds US surveillance aircraft to see the grey zone.

Grey-zone coercion at sea means using coast guards, maritime militias and harassment rather than warships to change facts without starting a war. This month's news shows the pattern across East Asia. The China Coast Guard says it monitored a Philippine resupply mission at a contested shoal, the latest in a long series of confrontations at Second Thomas and Scarborough shoals. Taiwan says it drove away 16 Chinese ships involved in 'maritime harassment'. The Philippine Coast Guard is strengthening surveillance with turboprop aircraft from the United States, so that it can document what happens at sea. Research adds depth: a study of 'anchors as weapons' examines Chinese grey-zone operations and their limits, a functionalist framework asks whether coast guards are police or military forces, and a paper on 'orbital blind spots' shows how satellites enable maritime coercion.

Essay

What the grey zone is

Grey-zone coercion is the use of force below the threshold of war. At sea it means coast guard cutters rather than destroyers, water cannon rather than missiles, fishing boats crewed by militia rather than marines, and anchors, lights and sheer numbers rather than gunfire. The aim is to change control of waters and reefs so gradually that no single incident justifies a military response. China has refined this method in the South China Sea for more than a decade, and now applies it around Taiwan and the Senkaku Islands.

This month's news is typical. The China Coast Guard says it 'monitored' a Philippine resupply mission at a contested shoal 3, a word that covers shadowing, blocking and, in past incidents, ramming and water cannon. Taiwan says it drove away 16 Chinese ships engaged in 'maritime harassment' 4.

Police force or military force?

The ambiguity is deliberate. Research proposes a functionalist framework for the South China Sea that asks whether a coast guard is acting as a police force, enforcing domestic law, or as a military force, asserting control against another state 6. China presents its coast guard as police enforcing Chinese law in Chinese waters, which makes any armed response by the Philippines look like an attack on law enforcement. The 2016 arbitral award rejected China's claims, but China ignores it, and the award has no enforcement mechanism.

A study of 'anchors as weapons' examines these operations in detail and finds limits to their effectiveness 5: coercion wins reefs but loses friends, pushing the Philippines, Japan and others closer to the United States.

The counter: see and show

The weaker side's best answer is transparency. The Philippines has pursued an 'assertive transparency' policy, filming and publishing every confrontation so that the world sees who uses water cannon. New turboprop surveillance aircraft from the United States 1 extend that ability to see. Research on 'orbital blind spots' shows the other side of the same contest: satellites enable maritime coercion by letting a navy track targets, and gaps in coverage become opportunities 7. The grey zone is fought with cameras and sensors as much as with ships.

Why it matters beyond the shoals

Grey-zone tactics test whether the law of the sea still governs. If a strong state can take control of disputed waters by harassment alone, every coastal state's exclusive economic zone becomes negotiable. Viet Nam, which has faced Chinese survey ships and militia in its own waters, watches the Philippine cases closely; the ASEAN Code of Conduct talks, now under Philippine chairmanship, are the diplomatic front of the same contest. The lesson of this month is that coercion at sea is a slow, documented, daily struggle rather than a crisis, and that the side that keeps its nerve and its cameras rolling holds the line.

Key developments

  • Confrontation at the shoals. The China Coast Guard says it monitored a Philippine resupply mission at a contested shoal. 3
  • Pressure on Taiwan. Taiwan says it drove away 16 Chinese ships involved in maritime harassment. 4
  • Seeing the grey zone. The Philippine Coast Guard is adding turboprop surveillance planes from the US, and received a patient transport vehicle from the state lottery. 12

Themes

  • Police or military?. Research asks whether coast guards are police forces or military forces, examines Chinese grey-zone operations and their limits, and shows how space-based sensing enables coercion at sea. 657

What to watch

  • The next Philippine resupply mission and China's response. 3
  • Chinese ship numbers around Taiwan. 4
Stories this analysis is based on (7)
  1. Philippine Coast Guard Bolsters Surveillance With Turboprop Planes From U.S. Eurasia Review
  2. PCSO turns over patient transport vehicle to Philippine Coast Guard Inquirer Global Nation
  3. China Coast Guard Says It Monitored Philippine Resupply Mission at Contested Shoal The Diplomat
  4. Taiwan says drives away 16 Chinese ships involved in ‘maritime harassment’ Hong Kong Free Press
  5. Anchors as weapons: Chinese maritime grey-zone operations and the limits of Chinese influence typologies Journal articles (OpenAlex)
  6. “Police force” or “military force”? A functionalist framework for the South China Sea Journal articles (OpenAlex)
  7. Orbital blind spots: dual-domain gray zone synergy and space-enabled maritime coercion in the Indo-Pacific Journal articles (OpenAlex)

Written by Claude (Anthropic), based on 7 recent headlines and excerpts in this section, Nov 11. AI analysis can misread or miss things: the numbers link to the original reporting, which is the authority.

Research 41

Journal articles, academic blogs, think-tank reports and papers, kept apart from the news below.

Journal articles (OpenAlex) Yu-Wen Chen · European Security Geopolitics

Anchors as weapons: Chinese maritime grey-zone operations and the limits of Chinese influence typologies

Existing typologies of Chinese influence in Europe organise activities into four categories: economic leverage, elite capture, information manipulation, and critical infrastructure positioning. This paper argues that Baltic Sea cable incidents since 2023 require a fifth-physical grey-zone operations-that existing frameworks cannot capture. Drawing on structured focused comparison of the Newnew Polar Bear (2023) and Yi Peng 3 (2024) cases, supplemented by comparison with…

Read at Journal articles (OpenAlex)

Journal articles (OpenAlex) Xiuying Li · Frontiers in Marine Science South China Sea

“Police force” or “military force”? A functionalist framework for the South China Sea

In the disputed maritime areas of the South China Sea, frequent coercive standoffs between state law enforcement vessels have made the demarcation between police force and military force a pressing legal issue. Through a comparative analytical approach, the dual administrative and military nature of coast guard agencies, paired with the absence of clear substantive limits on different types of weapons and use intensity, renders the traditional formalism-based approach…

Read at Journal articles (OpenAlex)

Journal articles (OpenAlex) Lourembam Japan Singh · Asian Security South China Sea

Orbital blind spots: dual-domain gray zone synergy and space-enabled maritime coercion in the Indo-Pacific

On 17 June 2024, eight China Coast Guard vessels rammed Philippine Navy inflatables at Second Thomas Shoal, amid a gray zone campaign that scholarship deems purely maritime. What enables the operational precision? Orbital architecture, this article argues. Through Civil-Military Fusion doctrine, China integrates satellite reconnaissance, GNSS spoofing, AIS manipulation, and communications jamming with maritime operations, producing dual-domain gray zone synergy: mutually…

Read at Journal articles (OpenAlex)

Journal articles (OpenAlex) Andrew Chubb, Luc Minh Tuan, Yen Pham Thi et al. · Australian Journal Of International Affairs South China Sea

Chinese public opinion’s role in the South China Sea: evidence from an expert survey

The prospect of Chinese nationalist public opinion driving a spiral of escalation in the South China Sea has been debated among analysts and policymakers for well over a decade. How do Southeast Asian claimant states and external great powers such as the United States interpret the role of Chinese public opinion in the South China Sea dispute, and how might this affect their policy preferences? This article uses a scenario-based survey experiment with international affairs…

Read at Journal articles (OpenAlex)

Journal articles (OpenAlex) Charles D.O. Pearson · The Pacific Review South China Sea

China’s zonation strategy in the South China Sea: repurposing maritime zones for security interests

This article conceptualises zonation strategy as a state practice that repurposes maritime zones, including EEZs, straight baselines, internal waters and other administrative or quasi-legal demarcations, to produce strategic effects at sea. Existing scholarship explains how the sea came to be zoned; I ask what states do with that fact. Zonation strategy operates through three intertwined modalities: a legal-strategic modality operating both within UNCLOS and beyond it…

Read at Journal articles (OpenAlex)

All 41 research items in this section

All news 58

The Manila Times Franco Jose C. Baroña South China Sea

‘Sea code should include 2016 arbitral ruling’

FORMER Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonio Carpio said the Philippines should refuse to sign any Code of Conduct (COC) in the South China Sea that does not incorporate the 2016 arbitral ruling, warning that an agreement that leaves the decision out could legitimize China’s expansive maritime presence and artificial island facilities. Carpio said the Philippines should not accept a deal that effectively freezes the current situation in the disputed waters, including…

Read at The Manila Times

The Manila Times Agence France-Presse South China Sea

Beijing bolsters South China Sea push with new island runway — analysts

TOKYO — China is building a runway on another island in the disputed South China Sea that could significantly strengthen its military footprint in the strategic waterway, according to experts and satellite images seen by AFP. Beijing claims most of the South China Sea, despite an international ruling that its assertion has no legal basis, and confrontations have occurred regularly with several Southeast Asian nations over control of the Paracel and Spratly islands. Both…

Read at The Manila Times

NASA Lauren E. Low Space

NASA to Cover 35th SpaceX Resupply Mission Space Station Departure

NASA and its international partners are set to receive scientific research samples and hardware as a SpaceX Dragon spacecraft departs the International Space Station no earlier than Wednesday, Nov. 18, for its return to Earth. Pending weather conditions, the Dragon spacecraft will undock from the Harmony module’s space-facing port at 11:05 a.m. EST, following a

Read at NASA

Nhân Dân (Vietnamese state media) South China Sea 2 publishers

Vietnamese Prime Minister Le Minh Hung attends 23rd ASEAN-India Summit

The PM called for closer cooperation to maintain peace, stability, security, safety and freedom of navigation and overflight in accordance with international law, particularly the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). He also proposed considering the establishment of an ASEAN-India maritime dialogue mechanism, and welcomed India’s consistent support for ASEAN’s principled stance on the East Sea/South China Sea. Viet Nam calls for stronger ASEAN–India…

Read at Nhân Dân (Vietnamese state media)

Also at VietnamPlus (Vietnamese state media)

The Manila Times Bernadette E. Tamayo South China Sea

Asean, China reaffirm 'firm commitment' to conclude the Code of Conduct in the South China Sea

MANILA, Philippines — President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. on Tuesday said the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) and China have reaffirmed "firm commitments" to finalize an effective and substantive Code of Conduct (COC) in the South China Sea (SCS). The completion of the COC -- which aims to govern the behavior of concerned parties at the SCS - was not achieved during the 49th Asean Summit and Related Summits as originally planned. But Asean and China "welcomed the…

Read at The Manila Times

The Manila Times Bernadette E. Tamayo South China Sea

China looks forward to early conclusion of Code of Conduct in South China Sea, says Premier Li

MANILA, Philippines — China looks forward to the early conclusion of the Code of Conduct (COC) in the South China Sea with the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean), which will provide a "solid institutional guarantee" for lasting peace and stability in the region. The Chinese Embassy in Manila said Chinese Premier Li Qiang made the remark during the 29th China-Asean Summit on Monday. "The two sides should promote regional development and prosperity," Li said. The…

Read at The Manila Times

South China Morning Post John Denholm Geopolitics

World can’t afford to take freedom of navigation for granted

Hong Kong’s success rests on its connection to the world. Its position as one of Asia’s great maritime and trading centres reflects a simple principle: prosperity depends on moving goods, connecting markets and trading freely across borders. That principle is as important today, during the 10th Hong Kong Maritime Week, as it was when Hong Kong first established itself as a major international port. At a time of growing geopolitical tensions, uncertainty over established…

Read at South China Morning Post

The Manila Times Franco Jose C. Baroña South China Sea

Fee for Chinese fishermen to access PH waters proposed

A CHINESE academic has proposed charging Chinese fishermen a fee to access the Philippines' 200-nautical-mile exclusive economic zone (EEZ). Dingli Shen, director of the Center for American Studies at Grandview Institution and professor emeritus at Fudan University's Institute of International Studies, proposed that Manila and Beijing negotiate an arrangement allowing Chinese fishing vessels into designated areas of the Philippine EEZ, provided they secure permits and pay…

Read at The Manila Times

The Manila Times Bernadette E. Tamayo South China Sea

PH needs more time to complete Code of Conduct in the South China Sea — Lazaro

MANILA, Philippines — The lack of time has forced the Philippines to "give up" the task of completing the Code of Conduct (COC) in the South China Sea between the Association of Southeast Asian Nations and China. Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro said the Philippines managed to achieve a "substantial completion" of the COC but it needed at least six more months to thresh out the "milestone issues" that hamper the completion of the COC. She reported the…

Read at The Manila Times

SCMP China Alyssa Chen South China Sea

South China Sea code of conduct: can Beijing and Asean meet 2026 deadline?

China and Southeast Asian nations have made progress in negotiating a code of conduct for the South China Sea, with Manila announcing that roughly 80 per cent of the draft agreement is complete. Yet whether the long-awaited accord can meet its year-end deadline comes down to Beijing and regional claimants finding common ground on key concessions, according to a Chinese expert. Philippine Foreign Secretary Theresa Lazaro said on Saturday after a series of Asean ministerial…

Read at SCMP China

The Guardian US Anna Betts

US Coast Guard suspends search for woman swept out to sea in California

Senah Park, 24, was last seen near Panther state beach on Sunday evening amid historic high tides and water levels The US Coast Guard announced that it has suspended its search for a 24-year-old woman who is believed to have been swept out to sea in California. The woman, identified as 24-year-old Senah Park, was last seen near Panther state beach in Santa Cruz county at about 8.30pm local time on Sunday, authorities said earlier this week.

Read at The Guardian US

Inquirer Global Nation nstamaria Geopolitics

PCSO turns over patient transport vehicle to Philippine Coast Guard

The Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office (PCSO) formally turned over a Patient Transport Vehicle (PTV) to the Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) on October 5, 2026, to strengthen its patient transport capabilities and support its medical, humanitarian, and emergency response operations. The turnover ceremony was led by PCSO General Manager Melquiades Robles, together with PCSO Chairman Judge

Read at Inquirer Global Nation

Hong Kong Free Press AFP

Taiwan says drives away 16 Chinese ships involved in ‘maritime harassment’

Taiwan said on Sunday it had driven away 16 Chinese coast guard, research and fishing vessels involved in simultaneous “maritime harassment” operations. An “unusually large” number of Chinese vessels took part in the coordinated operations around Taiwan’s main island and Pratas, a disputed island to the southwest, the Taiwanese coast guard said in a statement.

Read at Hong Kong Free Press

The Guardian NATO Guardian staff and agencies Geopolitics

Ukraine war briefing: Zelenskyy blames Russia for attack on Bulgarian vessels in Black Sea as investigation launched

Bulgarian authorities investigating origin of drone attack on two vessels in Nato member’s exclusive economic zone. What we know on day 1,687 Bulgaria’s prime minister said that two commercial vessels were struck by drones on Tuesday in the first attack on shipping in the Nato member’s exclusive economic zone in the Black Sea. Bulgarian authorities said the origin of the drones was under investigation, but Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy, blamed Russia for the drone…

Read at The Guardian NATO

The Guardian Cuba Reuters in Washington

US Coast Guard says it intercepted ship carrying fuel to Cuba

US says ship thought to be using common ‘dark fleet’ tactics was boarded and taken to Mexico as embargo continues The US Coast ⁠Guard has announced that it intercepted a large cargo ship carrying fuel bound for Cuba, as the ⁠Trump administration’s crippling ⁠oil embargo against ​the island nation continued. The vessel named Grace was stopped on 5 September in the Caribbean Sea between Cuba ⁠and Mexico while using tactics to evade authorities, the Coast Guard said. The New…

Read at The Guardian Cuba

Older stories